Using a flugelhorn instead of a trumpet to play this song
I decided to use a flugelhorn instead of the trumpet for my live performance due to a few reasons after I had completed my research. The trumpet and flugelhorn have two different sounds, therefore, I used this to decide on which instrument to use. I will relate this to research I will do into Michael Jackson's version of Human Nature.
To begin, the differences between a trumpet and a flugelhorn is shown in the image below.
- The cornet is the instrument at the top, below this is a flugelhorn.
- The smallest instrument in the image is a pocket trumpet
- The instrument at the bottom left is a flugelhorn
- The instrument to the right of the flugelhorn is the trumpet
This image is to show how these instruments contrast in terms of their shape.
(An image I got from twitter from a page called Fultone Brass) https://twitter.com/fultonebrass/status/876434805474418689
Trumpet Vs Flugelhorn
I watched a comparison video to help with the similarities and differences between these instruments.
This video is less of an explanation of the differences between these brass instruments and more of a demonstration. There are two instrumentalists in the video who play the trumpet and the flugelhorn.
Firstly, they are playing a duet with two flugelhorns and of a tune called Hail to the Chief which is a Presidential Anthem of the United States by James Sanderson.
I listened to this and I instantly thought that the flugelhorns played the piece in a softer tone than the trumpet would have which is the original sound of the instrument.
The flugelhorn duet is from 0:17 to 0:35 so it is a fairly short excerpt, however, enough to justify differences.
In my opinion, the way these brass players demonstrate with short excerpts is an advantage rather than a disadvantage(less time to listen to the instrument) because once the flugelhorn is played, you have the idea of the sound "stuck" in your head already. The excerpt is about 20 seconds long and I think that this is enough time to hear the qualities of the instrument before .
When the next sound (the trumpet follows) comes in, it instantly feels like something new. Also, the quicker the transition between the instruments, the more easier it is to differentiate them as the sounds are so close together. There are about three seconds after the flugelhorns have stopped playing and the trumpets come in.
Therefore, there are a few advantages to this video.
I then continued with the video to see if I can spot the differences in sound between the trumpet and flugelhorn myself.
What I gained from watching the whole of this video demonstration, the flugelhorns have a much softer tone than that of the trumpet. As soon as the trumpet comes in after the flugelhorns have stopped, there was a sharper tone to the ear.
Also, I would say that the trumpet sounds more "open". By this I mean loud, clear and prominent sounding. This contrasts to the flugelhorn which is the complete opposite to this "open" sound. I believe that the flugelhorn sounds more "muffled, dark" and had a sense of "calmness" to it. This is my description of the sounds coming from these instruments, however, the video is above to be listened to.
To conclude, it also helped that the trumpet and flugelhorn, for all of the excerpts, were playing the same tune. For example when the flugelhorns would play the song 'Ay Ziggy Zoomba', the trumpet would copy this note for note as these instruments are in exactly the same key, Bb. The reason for this being a positive aspect of the video is the ease of spotting the differences that I could listen to the trumpets and then rewind back to the flugelhorns playing the exact phrase and work from there.
Flugelhorn mouthpieces are like Cornet mouthpieces in that they have a deep funnel cup. However, Flugelhorn and Cornet mouthpieces cannot be interchanged as the diameter of the receiving pipe (the lead pipe-where the mouthpieces goes into) on the two instruments are different. This is the same for the mouthpieces on the trumpet and flugelhorn, they cannot be interchanged as the diameter of the receiving pipe on the instruments are different.The deeper the cup, the warmer the sound of the instrument. My flugelhorn came with a deeper mouthpiece than my trumpet which is one reason why they differ in sound. Therefore, a shallow cup, like my trumpet has, will produce a bright, open sound.
Trumpets are designed to play with a cup-shaped mouthpiece. This means that the interior of the mouthpiece is shaped like a cup and has what can be described as a c-shaped bowl. The opposite that a trumpet can have of this is a funnel-shaped mouthpiece. There will be no bowl in the interior, instead, the sides slope gradually from the rim to the throat.
I will make sure that the type of equipment I will use suits the song I am performing. I will compare the sounds of the trumpet and flugelhorn to the original song.This is because I would like my version of Human Nature to sound similar to the original but unique at the same time. The sound is something that I would make influence my 'Human Nature'. To do this, I will have to listen to Michael Jackson's vocals in the video on YouTube.
I will also make sure that the instrument I decided to use is available before I consider using it as I have to hire the flugelhorn.
To justify my options with using a flugelhorn or a trumpet, I will compare the sounds of both of these instruments with the original song by Michael Jackson.
Michael Jackson's Human Nature has a soft tone to it, especially in the vocals. This could have been done by electronic effects being added to his singing. An 'echo' (an electronic effect added to the vocals) is evident on the words 'why,why'.
Someone else had described the tone of Michael Jackson's singing as 'breathy'. A 'breathy' song is said to be associated with whisper singing. This is when the vocalist would not just sing quietly, but purposefully pushing out more air when they are singing. It is like projecting your voice but maintaining a whisper at the same time.
When Michael Jackson sings “if they say why, why? Tell them that it's human nature”, he drags out the word “why” in particular.
By dragging out the words for even a second more he gives his breath a chance to float along with the words rather than immediately cutting ff the air flow once the word has been sung. Michael Jackson also doesn’t try to breath quietly so at some points, you can hear his inhale and exhale.
To back up this research(due to some unreliable sources), I went oto another page using the same search I typed in. I was quite surprised at the similarity of the descriptions of the vocal sound.
The result (the song Human Nature) perfectly fit Michael's shy, breathy vocals, even though the plot involves hitting the clubs and snagging a one-night stand ( this is interpreted by the lyrics "If this town is just an apple," he sings, "then let me take a bite").
To conclude my finding, I would stick with my interpretation of the vocals having a 'soft, suttle' sound to them as this can be closely associated with the word 'breathy'. Therefore, I will now consider the flugelhorn as I have said previously that the mouthpiece of the flugelhorn will have an influence on the sound. The deeper the cup, the warmer the sound. So a shallow cup, like on a Trumpet, will produce a bright, open sound. This bright, open sound is not what we want for the soft, breathy vocals in 'Human Nature' as I think that this will give too much of an overpowering sound to the song. However, there is another way that the sound can be changed on the trumpet to alter it.
To conclude my finding, I would stick with my interpretation of the vocals having a 'soft, suttle' sound to them as this can be closely associated with the word 'breathy'. Therefore, I will now consider the flugelhorn as I have said previously that the mouthpiece of the flugelhorn will have an influence on the sound. The deeper the cup, the warmer the sound. So a shallow cup, like on a Trumpet, will produce a bright, open sound. This bright, open sound is not what we want for the soft, breathy vocals in 'Human Nature' as I think that this will give too much of an overpowering sound to the song. However, there is another way that the sound can be changed on the trumpet to alter it.
1In Miles Davis's Human Nature, which I have touched on earlier on in this blog, he used a mute in his trumpet. I noticed this when I listened to it because the 'sharp'sound of the trumpet was not there
The mute changes the sound of the trumpet.
A brass instrument mute doesn’t actually silence the brass instrument like the meaning of the word 'mute(much as some might wish it would). A mute changes the sound of the instrument in a certain way depending on the type of mute used. A mute for a brass instrument (trumpet, trombone, French horn, baritone horn) lowers the volume and alters the tonal quality/timbre of the instrument. The mute I use on my trumpet lowers the volume by a large amount and makes the trumpet sound 'smaller then the sound actually is(changing its timbre). The contrast from a open sound to a small, shy sound. I also think that the mute makes my trumpet sound 'squeaky' in a way.
A straight mute is shaped like a cone with the small open end going inside the bell of the brass instrument and the larger part of the cone sticking out of the bell. the mute is held in place inside the bell by three pieces of cork.I use a straight shaped mute on my trumpet.
This mute produces a kind of stuffy sound when it’s made from cardboard and a more piercing, brighter sound when made out of aluminum. This will note relate to my mute which is made of plastic. This could be why the sound descriptions are different.
Mutes go inside the bell of the brass instrument, using cork pressed against the inside of the bell to hold the mute in its place to prevent it from moving around.
Brass instrument mutes are sometimes used in Classical music, most likely the 20th and 21st century pieces. Igor Stravinsky, Gustav Mahler and Paul Hindemith are orchestral composers who make use of trumpet mutes in their compositions. My other song, Chanson Napolitaine is a classical piece. However, this song is performed on the trumpet without a mute.
- A brass player will also often use a mute to help lower the volume of their instrument when playing with a vocalist as the trumpet can be quite difficult to play in the same way quietly as you would do at a normal volume. This is due to the amount of air which is needed to play a low note and the speed of the air to play a higher note which can sometimes come out as a louder volume.
Miles Davis uses a Harmon mute in Human Nature. This is evident in the image.
The construction materials for a harmon mute is aluminium and some of the manufactures are Harmon, Jo-Ral and Tom Crown.
The mute can be played with the stem (the top of the mute)all the way inside, part way inside or left out all together.
This mute is used often in jazz by trumpeters Miles Davis and Dizzy Gilespie.
Miles Davis liked to play his trumpet using the Harmon mute with the stem removed completely from the mute.
The Harmon mute is also known as a “wah-wah” mute. When the brass player uses his or her hand to open and close the end of the mute, it makes a “wah-wah” sound.
The last process in this decision making is trying out what I found out
A trial performance is close and I will use this opportunity to perform with my flugelhorn as I have had various rehearsals with the trumpet preciously.This trial performance took place and at the end, my tutor gave me feedback and said that the flugelhorn sound suited the original sound of Human Nature which was good. This was my aim so I could take on this feedback and continue with using the flugelhorn.
From performing with the flugelhorn for the first time, I have noticed that it had changes my posture in a way. The valves on the flugelhorn are much higher that those on the trumpet. This means that I will be looking up most of the time and therefore, my back was straighter, my arms were at a reasonable level. This improves the trumpet playing and I have done some research in this topic of trumpet players posture in my other song, Chanson Napolitaine.
From performing with the flugelhorn for the first time, I have noticed that it had changes my posture in a way. The valves on the flugelhorn are much higher that those on the trumpet. This means that I will be looking up most of the time and therefore, my back was straighter, my arms were at a reasonable level. This improves the trumpet playing and I have done some research in this topic of trumpet players posture in my other song, Chanson Napolitaine.
I will evaluate the addition of the flugelhorn to my performance evaluation of the 12th June.
Where classical music is performed
To continue, I did some contextual research into the performance of classical works.
Together with the changing classical music, the concert venues were also changing. Classical music is not only performed in concert halls with thousands of seats as it was in the history of classical. A concert hall is simply a cultural building with a stage that serves as a performance venue and and an auditorium (room built to enable an audience to hear and watch performances) filled with seats.
While early halls built in the 18th and 19th century were designed for classical orchestra, concerto and opera concerts and ballet performances, halls built in the 20th and 21st century were often built to accommodate a wider range of performance types, such as solos or musicals. In the 2010s, popular music such as rock music and traditional music such as folk music are also performed in these venues. This relates to my other song, Human Nature which incorporates some rock and pop elements.
The performance of Human Nature shows that these genres of music (this song incorporates quite storm, soft rock and rhythm and blues) have started to be performed in Concert halls and how this has developed from when only classical music was performed in these venues.
I will now be showing some examples of classical pieces which were performed in a concert hall on the trumpet. Don Pasquale, which was mentioned earlier on in the blog. This video is combined with 'Rondo for Life' by Bernstein.
In the second video down, Alison Bolsom, a classical trumpeter, is playing a Haydn Trumpet Concerto in Eb, the 1st movement.
She is playing with the orchestra. With the instrumental families of strings and woodwind, percussion.
An orchestra is a group of instruments, each from different families of instruments, for example the brass or string family.
The Classical era, which covers roughly the second half of the 18th century, is one of the most significant periods in the development of orchestration where the orchestra became standardised. The Classical orchestra came to consist of strings (first and second violins, violas, violoncellos, and double basses), two flutes, two oboes, two clarinets, two bassoons, two or four horns, two trumpets, and two timpani.
Haydn introduced clarinets as part of the woodwind section toward the the end of his career in the London Symphonies which was a change that was to be permanent.
Haydn also introduced the following innovations: trumpets were used independently(solo) instead of always doubling the horns, cellos became separated from the double basses, and woodwind instruments were often given the main melodic line. In the Military Symphony (No. 100) Haydn introduced some percussion instruments not normally used in the orchestras of this time, namely, triangle, hand cymbals, and bass drum; and, what is still more unusual, they are employed in the second movement, which in the Classical tradition is normally the slow movement.
One of the current orchestras present today is the London Philharmonic Orchestra.
Mozart, another classical composer, too, was responsible for great strides in the creative use of instruments of the orchestra. His last two symphonies (Nos. 40, K 550, and 41, K 551) are among the most beautifully orchestrated works of this or any period. For his 17 piano concertos, Mozart exhaustively explored the combination of piano and orchestra.
Back to the point about the venues where classical music is performed, nowadays, there are also performances in cabaret-style venues where audience members sip beer and wine while enjoying Beethoven and Chopin. Beethoven is a classical composer and I know one of Chopin's works called the 'Raindrop' prelude which I have analysed in the past. This is a romantic piece which links to his history, Chopin was a composer in the romantic era.
I researched into the venues of where classical music was performed because my tutor explained to me that there is reverberation if a trumpeter would perform a classical piece in a concert hall.
I did some research to back this up to make sure that this information was correct.
The reverberation time of a hall is the oldest and one of the most important measures of a good concert hall. Reverberation is the decay of sound after a note has stopped being played. This means there will be a slight sound after the note has been played. It is mostnoticeable in a large space with hard surfaces, which is what a concert hall is, a large space. A cathedral where the sound echoes around long after a note has finished is also an example of this. In small spaces with plenty of soft materials, such as a bedroom, the sound is quicklyabsorbed by the soft furnishings, and dies away rapidly. These type of rooms, small spaces is where I had practiced and recorded my classical piece 'Chanson Napolitaine' which could be the reason that there was no reverb in my trumpet part.
To top this up, the most commonly perceived quality of room acoustics is how sound energy decays in a space, referred to as the room’s reverberation. In a large gothic cathedral, the sound takes a long time to die away, sometimes up to 9 seconds, surprisingly. In a small conference room, however, the sound does not linger but decays very rapidly such as in the practice rooms at Leyton Sixth Form. Longer reverberation generally accentuates music, but can cause speech to be muddled such as for a vocalist. For concert halls, musicians will often refer to a reverberant space as being very “live” due to the sound it will give. I noticed that when there is reverberation on something the sound is much brighter and open, it sounds more like a "live" performance, especially for classical works. If there is not very much sound reverberation, a hall may be referred to as being “dead”.
Today, I had another studio session where I took on this contextual references and added them to my tracks.
This is the sound of Chanson Napolitaine without the reverb. I filmed most of the track so that you can have an idea of the sound before this was changed.
Now I will play to you the version of Chanson Napolitaine with the added reverb and automation.
I mentioned that automation was added to Chanson Napolitiaine aswell. Chanson Napolitaine was recorded in parts. This meant that I split the piece up into three sections and played on section at a time, stopping and starting the recording each time. Therefore, some things had changed during the process of this. The most likely thing that could have happened is that I changed the position of the trumpet to the microphone. Tis could make some parts appear louder and some quieter which was present in my track.
While it is tempting to get all of your levels set for each individual track, it is rare that all the levels that sound great on one part of a song will continue to sound that great throughout the rest of the song. This is evident in Chanson Napolitaine and shown in the first video above ("The sound of Chanson Napolitaine without the reverb. The name of the reverb which was added onto my trumpet part is called Bright Hall Reverb.
I filmed most of the track so that you can have an idea of the sound before this was changed.") these cases, automating certain aspects of the tracks during different parts of the song can be a great way to produce a consistent, great sounding song from start to finish.
I filmed most of the track so that you can have an idea of the sound before this was changed.") these cases, automating certain aspects of the tracks during different parts of the song can be a great way to produce a consistent, great sounding song from start to finish.
As the number of tracks available to recoring engineers grew throughout the 1970s, mixers ran into a problem. This problem was that the final mix down typically consists of slight adjustments to the volume levels of individual tracks throughout the song, and when there were 24 tracks on the songs, engineers just didn’t have enough hands to make all the changes themselves. Chanson Napolitaine doesn't have this many tracks. What happened, then, was that the engineers gathered pretty much anyone that was in the studio around the mixing board, assigned them a couple of tracks to manually adjust during the mix down that made the final mix.

These days, contrasting to back then, even though there are many more tracks available to engineers, the issue of adjusting levels has been solved by automation. Rather than waiting until the final stage of the mix, engineers can automate volume levels, panning and much more while they are mixing.


No comments:
Post a Comment